Galactic Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches

Prefer to bake with a digital recipe card? Use this link.

From Your Kitchen

Here's a list of what you'll need from your kitchen.

How to Make the Box


Questions and answers will be added here. Have a question? Email

We would love to answer any questions you have. Happy baking!

Best Practices

Fold gently. When adding the sweetened condensed milk to the whipped heavy cream, gently fold to keep the mixture somewhat airy.  Fold and mix until it is thoroughly combines but still fluffy. 

Don't over mix the creams! When pulling your butter knife through the three colors of cream, make sure you stop before they are all mixed. Color definition is key. 

Freeze cream for 6-10 hours. It can be tempting to remove the ice cream from the freezer prematurely. Wait several hours until it is fully hardened to make sure you have a cold and stable ice cream sandwich.  That said, if your freezer is really cold, the ice cream can be pretty hard. Let the firmed ice cream sit out for a couple minutes before scooping. If you accidentally left it out too long, you can scoop the centers into the cookies then refreeze them in a sealed container.